Pollster.com

Articles and Analysis

 

Opinion on Libby Sentence Commutation


1LibbyLibCon.png

SurveyUSA has a poll of immediate reaction to President Bush's decision to commute the prison sentence of Scooter Libby. SurveyUSA uses Interactive Voice Response (IVR) "automated" polling rather than human interviewers. But for a quick reaction poll of a breaking news story, this poll shows the advantages of speed that are possible with IVR technology.

SurveyUSA interviewed 1500 adults nationally within three hours or so of the news that President Bush had commuted the sentence. Of the full sample 55% (825) said yes to the question: "Are you familiar with the legal case involving former White House employee Scooter Libby?"

Those 825 were then asked

    President Bush has commuted the portion of Scooter Libby's sentence that would have required Libby to serve 30 months in prison. Libby remains a convicted felon - he still must pay a 250 thousand dollar fine and serve 2 years of probation - but he will not go to prison. Based on what you now know, should the President have pardoned Scooter Libby completely? Should the president have taken no action, and left the prison sentence in place? ... Or, do you agree with the president's decision to commute the prison portion of the Libby sentence?

As SurveyUSA points out, an advantage of the instant poll is that it can measure opinion before the inevitable political spin begins to affect opinion.

One problematic issue is that SurveyUSA filtered respondents for awareness of the Libby case. I suspect a number of polls to be taken over the next few days will vary in whether the filter for awareness or not, making direct comparison among all the polls to come somewhat difficult. By applying this filter, SurveyUSA should be expected to include people with greater awareness of the issues in the Libby case and presumably more settled opinions on this case than if they had included all 1500 respondents, including the 45% who said they were not familiar with the case. Given the discussion the Libby case has received on talk radio, blogs and MSM it is interesting that 45% didn't feel they were familiar with the case. This opens considerable opportunity for opinion to be swayed either direction in the next couple of days.

But what of those who were familiar?

Not surprisingly, 79% of liberals wanted to see Libby serve his sentence, with only 9% approving Bush's decision and 11% wanting a full pardon. Moderates were only a little less bent on punishment: 69% wanted prison time, while 19% approved the commutation and 11% wanted a full pardon. But what surprises me is the Conservatives. They broke into rough thirds: 31% wanted a complete pardon and 31% approved the decision, but a surprising 35% thought Libby should have served his prison sentence. For all the talk of the President needing to respond to a conservative base fired up for a full pardon, this evidence suggests the President has failed to satisfy two-thirds of that base. (And one should always remember that what we hear on conservative talk radio is a substantial exaggeration of the homogeneity of opinion within that base. Grass roots conservatives (as with grass roots liberals) are considerably more variable in their opinions than radio shows would suggest.)

If we shift to partisanship we see a similar but not identical distribution. Democrats favored prison by 77%, approved the commutation by 14% and 8% thought a full pardon was called for. Fifty-six percent of Independents wanted jail, with 20% approving the President and 21% wanting a pardon. But again when we come to the Republican base, we find a really surprising 40% saying the Libby should have served time in prison. Thirty-two percent supported Bush's decision while 26% wanted a pardon.

Now we might expect to see lowering of support for prison among conservatives and Republicans over the next few days as Republican opinion leaders send the message that they support the commutation (assuming they send that message). And it will be interesting to see if subsequent polling agrees with this instant snapshot from SurveyUSA. But the commentary going into this action by Bush stressed the dilemma he faced between satisfying the base and further offending independents and moderates. So far, the evidence is that the action he took has failed even to please a majority of the Republican and conservative base.

This should be interesting to watch.

2LibbyPID.png

Revision: This version of the graphics scale the column widths in proportion to the size of each group (Lib,Mod,Con) or (Dem,Ind,Rep). The first plots failed to do that. My bad. Thanks to Peter Flom for bringing the mistake to my attention.

Cross-posted at Political Arithmetik.

 

Comments
gjdodger:

I would like to see the reaction of the other 45% to the case if it was presented hypothetically. I would guess a larger majority of those people would say the perpetrator belongs in jail. I can't imagine many people who just go about their daily lives and don't follow Washington intricacies, when presented the details of the case, would suggest the sentence was too harsh.

____________________

Ellen:

I just listened to Keith Olbermann's heroic response to the pardoning of the convicted criminal, Scooter Libby. I'm an independent and a moderate in my politics, but I am in complete agreement with Keith. It is horrific to have such an immoral person inhabiting the highest office of our land. We need to impeach these two crooks (bush/cheney) immediately if we truly care about America...political party be damned. This is about America, not about partisan politics. Do we care about the law or not? Do we care about our nation or not? Apparently there are a lot of right wingers who do NOT care about our nation or the law and who will go to any lengths, however criminal, for their party. I wonder just what IS in their koolade? And speaking of criminals, why is Karl Rove still roving this land? He is the ultimate traitor and should be locked away for life.

____________________

Ellen:

I just listened to Keith Olbermann's heroic response to the pardoning of the convicted criminal, Scooter Libby. I'm an independent and a moderate in my politics, but I am in complete agreement with Keith. It is horrific to have such an immoral person inhabiting the highest office of our land. We need to impeach these two crooks (bush/cheney) immediately if we truly care about America...political party be damned. This is about America, not about partisan politics. Do we care about the law or not? Do we care about our nation or not? Apparently there are a lot of right wingers who do NOT care about our nation or the law and who will go to any lengths, however criminal, for their party. I wonder just what IS in their koolade? And speaking of criminals, why is Karl Rove still roving this land? He is the ultimate traitor and should be locked away for life.

____________________

Sisyphus:

Outrageous as it may be, the commutation -- if we're to believe legal scholars -- is probably not impeachable.
In a way then, it can distract from the many other offenses that are impeachable like warrantless spying.
Some legal scholars have suggested that Congress focus on ONE impeachable offense and go for it. It would not get through the Senate with its razor-thin Dem majority, but it would serve to tie this Bush/Cheney crime family in knots.

____________________

Jack Ballard:

"Outrageous as it may be, the commutation -- if we're to believe legal scholars -- is probably not impeachable"

The impeachment process is not a court of law. An impeachable offense is determined by the House. High crimes and misdemeanors is a broad category.
Jack

____________________

Matthew D Rosin:

Yeah. Ellen. You are a moderate independent like I'm Abbey Hoffman.

I wouldn't have pardoned the guy, for pretty clear reasons. He had a trial. He has appeals. Tim Russert is incapable of faulty memory. Etc.

But... Are you for bloody real in believing that it's just the Republicans who are infested with lies, hubris and corruption?

And finally, Olbermann is heroic? It was with that word that you tipped down your rabid leftist blinders. He's an opinion journalist in a field so sympathetic to his views that he probably gets a handjob at every industry soire he attends. And that's just from Chris Matthews.

I love that you have passion for our country, or is it just angry hate?

Grow up.

____________________

Bert Wayne:

Born, lived in and near Berk, Ca, for 85
for 85 yrs. You trotted out Willie Brown
this eve: We had a saying back when thetwo Browns were running Calif: "If it's
Brown,flush it"! We did! Willie
went dn the Political sewer to
be the crowned Mayor of SF, Regan
replaced the hero of the Demo's
of Ca, similar to the demise of Davis.
Moon-Boy appeared for s ahort stay,
in Sac: from debts owed his father.
Ah, Politics is so $$ fruitful $$.

____________________



Post a comment




Please be patient while your comment posts - sometimes it takes a minute or two. To check your comment, please wait 60 seconds and click your browser's refresh button. Note that comments with three or more hyperlinks will be held for approval.

MAP - US, AL, AK, AZ, AR, CA, CO, CT, DE, FL, GA, HI, ID, IL, IN, IA, KS, KY, LA, ME, MD, MA, MI, MN, MS, MO, MT, NE, NV, NH, NJ, NM, NY, NC, ND, OH, OK, OR, PA, RI, SC, SD, TN, TX, UT, VT, VA, WA, WV, WI, WY, PR